Author Topic: Stitch Method Dr Merck  (Read 7059 times)

Offline argosy2012

  • New Member
  • *
  • Posts: 4
    • View Profile
Stitch Method Dr Merck
« on: January 25, 2012, 08:15:47 PM »

newbielink:http://www.ear-clinic.com/otoplasty/ear-operation-videos.html?id=20 [nonactive]

Method in this video, , Is it worth having it done,
Are the results permanent
Simple solution to a basic otoplasty where no reshaping of an ear is needed/?

Offline DrBermant

  • Plastic Surgeon - Site Owner
  • Administrator
  • Mentor Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1166
    • View Profile
    • Bermant Plastic Surgery
Otoplasty Forum - Re: Stitch Method Dr Merck
« Reply #1 on: January 25, 2012, 08:52:01 PM »
Method in this video, , Is it worth having it done,
Are the results permanent
Simple solution to a basic otoplasty where no reshaping of an ear is needed/?

I have addressed this question in another post:

Quote
Hi
I really wanted to have my ears fixed by you, But you retired ,
Who can i now trust to fix my ears, The stick out, very badly,
Who can do all the various reshaping, like helix rim, so on,
Most places go a basic otoplasty op, My helix rim needs reshaping to, along with
fixing my ears so the don't stick out,
Also what do you make of Dr Merks Stitch Method Otoplasty  ??

Yes, Plastic Surgery of the Ears is a true art form. One surgical maneuver  does not fit all deformities. I preferred blending my Dynamic Techniques to adapt to the actual ear deformity. When the Helix rim is a component of the deformity, sometimes it can be incorporated into the sculpture.

I have posted resources on How to Pick Your Otoplasty Surgeon. You really need to look at the surgeons' work, not just read the verbal hype.

That is the problem I have seen with the technique you ask about. You can find basic comments here on this post about "Incisionsless" Surgery: Does it Work?. I have seen so many patients over the years unhappy after that particular method was supposedly used. I still have not found any decent demonstration of successful cases. To critically evaluate results you need to look at more than one picture of the ears. Check out How to Evaluate Otoplasty Ear Pictures. My concerns about validity of results are further heightened when a surgeon does not put the before and after pictures together as I saw today on one such supposed demonstration of results. Why if the technique works, cannot those advocating it demonstrate it with many cases. Beyond that glaring poor method of demonstration, the results shown look like cases I saw of unhappy patients who came to my office. Once you looked at the ear from the different views I evolved for my Standard Pictures for Otoplasty, the true nature of the problem becomes apparent.

This should not be construed as medical advice. I am a retired Board Certified Plastic Surgeon.

I am not fluent in German. I had a difficult time wading through the half hour video, but did not see anything that changed my opinion of what I saw. I saw a single picture taken. That is not enough in my opinion to document a problem nor the solution. The ear is a complex shape and needs to be seen in person or from enough angles to appropriately understand the contours.

To evaluate if a procedure works, there should be before and after surgery pictures directly next to each other as pointed out in the above post. I did not see any on that site at the time of this review. I have looked for such documentation many times in the past and yet to see good results. Single view documentation is just not adequate. Severe deformities can be hidden with limited views. This become more suspicious as the views picked change from patient to patient.

Over the years, I have seen many patients unhappy after operations done elsewhere who claimed their surgeon used this method. That does not mean that something does not work. Why should a happy patient come to me anyway? However, it should be the obligation of the doctor offering the operation to prove it works.

Welcome to our forum. This is a place where others can post their success stories, questions, and opinions. This forum was designed for those with concerns to be able to discuss them and permit those with passions to sculpt, demonstrate their skills.

Hope this helps,

Michael Bermant, MD
Learn More About Otoplasty Ear Surgery
Michael Bermant, MD
Retired Plastic Surgeon
Surgical Sculptor, Artist, Creative Thinker, Problem Solver
Plastic Surgery
Follow DrBermant on Twitter
Like us on Facebook:
Encyclopedia News
Forum Updates

 

anything